Someone just pointed out this Slate article about a new website called Modern Loss. The article says:
"Americans love to talk about people who overcome the odds to survive serious injury or illness, but we don't cope with death very well. Enter Modern Loss, a new website dedicated to helping us stop treating death and grief like embarrassments to be hidden away, and instead have an honest conversation about what it means to mourn.
The site was started by two women, Rebecca Soffer and Gabrielle Birkner, who lost parents at an early age and who are clearly opposed to the toxic forced optimism [emphasis mine, because I LOVE this phrase] of American culture that can make grief all the more difficult. They promise a website that will be free of people adjudicating how sad you're allowed to feel and a complete ban on the phrase, 'everything happens for a reason.'"Did you hear me cheering at that last line? Please, oh please, can we get rid of that platitude?
![]() |
There, now it's fixed! |
So I had to check out Modern Loss, and right away I found a lot to like, especially one post: The Reverse Midas Touch.
While my recent string of losses hasn't been as drastic as what author Abby Sher describes, it has made me wonder if I'm—if not cursed—maybe attracting bad stuff into my life in some subconscious way. Short answer: NO, I don't believe in hocus-pocus. But still, honestly, there are times when I have kind of felt like a freak. There are times when I've been ashamed of my own apparent Sadim (the reverse of Midas) Touch.
Right after my miscarriage, I happened to see this video about stillbirth. The parts that resonated most were the parents who talked about feeling like a bad-luck charm, and those who said that the worst thing was when people refused to talk about their child at all. That is "toxic forced optimism" at work.
I do understand the impulse; I've been guilty of it, too. But I've come to see another way: simple, loving presence. Abby Sher offers it to a sick friend at the end of her post. Others have offered it to me.
One particular time stands out: after the baby’s heartbeat stopped and before the bleeding started, a friend put his hand on my belly and just held it there, silently, head bowed. That simple act of acknowledging that he/she was real and still mattered, even after death ... of coming closer instead of running away ... it was one of the most healing things anyone has ever done for me.
Oh wow. That last paragraph...what an amazing friend, and what a powerful moment. I wish I had done that for myself after my miscarriage.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing the website - lots of wonderful articles.
That's interesting, what you said about wishing you had done that for yourself. I had trouble with it, actually -- had some very mixed feelings toward my body right then, and just didn't want to stand still and be present. He helped me, gently, to do so.
DeleteThat story about your friend putting his hand on your belly...brought me to tears. So simple and beautiful and profound. And, I can imagine, very comforting in that moment.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great sounding site. It's coming at a particularly timely moment for me, as I nurture new life while also processing renewed grief. The pressure I am feeling from some of those around me to 'focus on the positive', and the guilt I sometimes feel for not looking after this baby well enough when I do break down, are overwhelming. But I want to continue finding ways to continue honouring that grief, because I still think there are so many worhtwhile life lessons in mourning and remembering. Thank you so much for sharing Hope.
Sharing things that have helped me is always a pleasure. I owe lots of my sanity to having these places to read, talk, and write about what's really going on, "positive" or not.
DeleteSadie, I'm sure that your baby isn't hurt by your emotions, and that she/he benefits from all the healthy things you've no doubt been doing. Looking after your family and yourself, while honoring S and all that's come before -- that's a lot to navigate. I'm learning from you.
Wow! I love what your friend did. So nice. I also love the website. Life is so unfair and sometimes it gets really hard to deal with it...
ReplyDeleteYes. And when things feel so bad, sometimes the smallest kindness can stand out and make a real difference.
DeleteWhat your friend did made me tear up. I am so glad you have him in your life and that he acknowledged your little one like that.
ReplyDeleteI've never heard of this site, but just from what you've posted here, I think I'll like it. "Everything happens for a reason." is one of my least favorite platitudes since losing the baby.
The website is brand new, but I'd say it's getting off to a great start.
DeleteUgh, I HATE that platitude, along with "Whatever doesn't kill me makes me stronger." Someone I know has an email signature that says, "Whatever doesn't kill me ... had better start running!" I like that one better. :)
Thank you for posting about this. I don't know if you've seen it but there is a great recent article about miscarriage. I will be keeping my eye on the site for sure!
ReplyDeleteI did see that article -- yes, also very good!
Delete